Monday, May 30, 2016

Review: Wink Poppy Midnight by April Genevieve Tucholke

Wink Poppy Midnight by April Genevieve Tucholke
Wink Poppy Midnight
By April Genevieve Tucholke
Dial Books
Format: Print ARC
Source: YALLFest

To Sum It Up: Wink Poppy Midnight follows the intertwined stories of three very different characters. Midnight, a sensitive and unusual young boy finds himself caught in between two very different girls. Poppy, the beautiful and very mean girl refuses to relinquish her claim on Midnight, but the strange and fairytale obsessed Wink seems to be winning him over. A haunted house in the woods will force the characters to reveal who they really are.

Review: I am somewhat ashamed to admit that I got this ARC while at YALLFest, but the important thing is that I finally got to read it! I have been in a severe book hangover since reading The Raven King, but Wink Poppy Midnight was the perfect book to help me out of the dark depths of depression. It was a quick and enjoyable read with short chapters and fluid transitions that kept the pace moving. That being said, I was able to finish it in a matter of hours. Although the book was nothing like I expected (I thought it was going to be paranormal for some strange reason) it successfully accomplished capturing the extraordinary in the ordinary. The complex characters, the fairytale-esque setting, and the shocking end worked well together to pull the reader into the world of the novel.

I love a good book with a haunted house, and Wink Poppy Midnight truly delivered. Throw in a charming farm and a wooded area and you have the perfect recipe for a place where anything can (and does) happen. While the characters are somewhat ordinary high school students, this setting is an excellent opportunity to do more extraordinary things while away from the routine normality of school.

Another thing I enjoyed about this story was the complexity of the characters. No one is truly what they seem, and I love when characters defy the expectations of the reader. I thought Wink, Poppy, and Midnight were somewhat gray characters, and I think that complexity brought the story to another level. Watching them reveal themselves to each other threw me for quite a loop. Although I did not particularly like any of the characters, I still had a lot of fun reading about them. Yes, I know how very little sense that makes, but it’s true!

Surprise endings can be a hit or miss with me. My golden rule is that above all else, the ending must fit the characters, and I was very pleased to find that this one did just that! The pace of the novel kept the reader moving quickly, so the end is even more of a jolt (but in a very good way!).

All in All: Wink Poppy Midnight was a quick and enjoyable read. It is definitely not what it appears to be, but I thought that was what made it appealing. I didn’t find anything wrong with this book, but for whatever reason this book was not able to work its way into my heart. That being said, you should really give this one a try!


  1. Oh this sounds very promising Lee^^ I've seen this one around quite a bit but I didn't have a set idea in my mind as to what to expect here...but: haunted houses, gray characters, and a feeling that anything can happen sounds GREAT! Glad you loved this one AND that it was able to help you deal with the TRK+ACOMAF hangovers XD

    1. OMG I just realized that this is Melissa's review and not Lee's (oops! - sorry Melissa) Loved your review nonetheless LOL!

  2. I sadly didn't like this one, because I HATED the characters and really couldn't warm up to them or like them in the tiniest bit, but I'm glad it wasn't so bad for you! Great review :)

    1. I could only get so invested in the characters because I didn't particularly like them either. I guess I was really interested to see where the story was going anyway. XD

  3. I have that problem sometimes with how my reviews are set up to list the good, the bad, the romance and the conclusion. Sometimes, there may not be anything to put under the bad section, but it still wasn't a four or five star level read. I'm glad you enjoyed this one though. It seems like a very unique story. Great review!


We love hearing from our readers and do our best to reply. Thank you for taking the time to leave a comment!