Alison Can Read. It's a great way to meet other book bloggers!
This week's question is:
Do you mind books with similar ideas to other books? Similar concepts, backgrounds, retellings or pulled-to-publish fanfic?
Not really, just as long as there's some kind of fresh twist to the concept, like with Marissa Meyer's cyborg Cinderella in Cinder or Bethany Griffin's steampunk take on Edgar Allan Poe's short story in Masque of the Red Death. We never would have read as many vampire books as we have if they'd all been just another rehash of Twilight. Coming up with an entirely new, never-before-seen idea for a book has to be really difficult, so when it comes to retellings or books with jacket blurbs that say, "If you liked Book X, you're sure to love Book Y," what we look for is how the author has put his or her own stamp on a particular premise.
If you're a new follower, be sure to let us know so that we can follow you back. Thanks for stopping by!
Agreed! Old follower via GFC. My FFs are at Musings on Fantasia and LKHill. Happy Friday! :D
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by!
DeleteNever mind Twilight, we wouldn't have the vampire books we have today if it weren't for rehashing Dracula. :)
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by - new follower.
Bob @ Beauty in Ruins
So true! And it's Bram Stoker's birthday today, too!
DeleteThanks for following!
I am not a fan-fic fan at all. I don't read any of that stuff. But I don't mind a new spin on other stories if the author twists it around a little. Some stories are so universal that it’s almost a given that they will be retold, like The Iliad and the Odyssey. The story is an archetype of the hero’s journey.
ReplyDeleteNew follow via GFC.
Julie~ New Adult Addiction
I don't read fanfic either; I've just never been interested. Great examples there of two works with timeless, universal themes- The Iliad and The Odyssey!
DeleteThanks for following!
Well, yes. I don't mind if it's a retelling of a story.
ReplyDeleteNew follower~
Cindy @ http://bookaholicfaggots.blogspot.com
I don't mind, either, so long as there's a new angle to the story. Thanks for following!
DeleteI agree with you! As long as there's some kind of twist I'll probably enjoy it. New follower via GFC.
ReplyDeleteHere's my #FF
Oops old follower. xD
DeleteThat's how I feel, too- I like seeing new life breathed into an existing concept. Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteGreat answer and thanks for stopping by my blog! I'm a new follower via GFC, Linky, & Networked Blogs.
ReplyDeleteRamblings of a Coffee Addicted Writer
Thanks for dropping by and following!
DeleteHopping through. I like that a lot of authors have jumped on the vampire bandwagon. There are so many ways to make the same paranormal creature feel fresh and different.
ReplyDeleteMy Hop
I like the various takes that there have been on different paranormal beings. I really don't remember these kinds of YA books existing when I was a teen, so maybe that's why I love reading them so much now, as an adult.
DeleteThanks for dropping by!
So very true! If there are fresh twists and originality, then why not? Great answer. Thanks for stopping by my FF post! Old follower. :)
ReplyDeleteMy FF post @ Her Fiction Fix
I'm willing to try any book, even if I think it's very similar to something I've already read, because you never know how that particular author is going to write about that particular subject. If I'd dismissed every book that I thought was too much like something else I'd read before, I'd have missed out on A LOT of great books.
DeleteThanks for dropping by!
AGREED! I also think it's going to be a LOT harder soon, if not already, for paranormal/fantasy/sci-fi authors to come up with extremely original ideas. Everything these days seems to have derived from one popular thing, and everyone and their mother is trying to cash in. *sigh*..I may give those genres a break for a while.
ReplyDeleteOld Follower via GFC =)
_______________
Reeka @BoundbyWords
Check out my FF here.
As much as I love paranormal, I need a break from it too, sometimes. What I tend to get burnt out on really fast are dystopians, especially when the world-building is on the shaky side.
DeleteThanks for dropping by!
Cinder was pretty good; I liked the futuristic take on the original fairytale. Thanks for dropping by!
ReplyDeleteGreat answer!
ReplyDeleteHere's my FF Post!
Andrea @ Literary Getaway
Old Follower(:
That's a clever answer! I like how you stressed on the 'if you liked so-and-so book, you're sure to like this new book'. Great stuff! :)
ReplyDeleteThe Readdicts Feature & Follow Friday post
New follower here!
Sarika @ The Readdicts
A lot of times I do end up liking a book with that kind of blurb on the jacket, but once in a while it doesn't work out because the book is practically a clone of another that I've read.
DeleteThanks for stopping by!
Hi!
ReplyDeleteI agree with you!
New follower via GFC :)
My F&F: http://nightmareonbookstreet.blogspot.com/2012/11/feature-and-follow-2.html
Thanks for stopping by and following!
DeleteLove your answer! I think you've pretty much summed up my thoughts about this--and in such an eloquent way!
ReplyDeleteThanks Joie! I'm glad it made sense in the end because it started out as one big ramble, lol.
DeleteAgree :)
ReplyDeleteExisting follower, hopping through :)
Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteLove your answer- especially that last line! Thanks for stopping by, old GFC follower!
ReplyDeleteMy #FF
~Caitlin :)
Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteWell said, Darlings! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks Ali!
DeleteGreat answer! I agree there has to be some elements that are borrowed at some point. I think essentially every book was influenced in one way or another by other books. I just can't stand when it's SO similar that you feel like you've read the book before :) Thanks for sharing and here's my FFF this week.
ReplyDeleteMicheline @ Lunar Rainbows
I know what you mean- when I start getting déjà vu while reading a book, I know that it's not going to work out. Thanks for stopping by!
DeleteExactly! Good answer.
ReplyDeleteold follower
http://itchingforbooks.blogspot.com/2012/11/feature-and-follow-25_9.html
Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteThere are some genres where books have become too similar that it really puts me off. Having said that, I don't mind if they are slightly similar, as long as there is a fresh angle. New follower. Here's mine: My FF
ReplyDeleteTo me, a lot of the dystopian novels that I've read have had way too similar premises, and I can't read too many of them in a row.
DeleteThanks for stopping by and following!
Just blogging by, good answer.
ReplyDeletehttp://tributebooksmama.blogspot.com/2012/11/feature.html
Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteGreat answer, Lee
ReplyDeleteI don't like the rash of re-telling that has gone on - things that pit supernatural things into already existed stories, like the Abe Lincoln Vampire Hunter sort of thing but I love when people build on existing mythology in a "standing on the shoulders of giants" sort of way. All storytelling is essentially stealing anyway.
Very true! Out of curiosity, I tried reading Pride and Prejudice and Zombies a while back but ended up skimming most of it because to me it read like a cut and paste job, with the zombie parts just thrown in here and there. I like retellings where it's obvious that a lot of thought has been put into reimagining the original source and making the new version stand on its own legs.
DeleteThanks for stopping by Ally!
I haven't read Cinder yet, but I have it on my TBR, and I've read the prequel (I think).
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by my
FF post earlier, I am following back via Twitter, and am also following via Networked Blogs :)
Have a wonderful weekend.
Cinder is a really nice example of a creative retelling. I hope you get the chance to read it soon!
DeleteThanks for the Twitter and NB follows!
Really great answer! I loved the Twilight comment and I LOVED CINDER! I don't mind retellings or similar topics as long as there's some originality to the story.
ReplyDeleteOld follower :) Happy Friday!
Judith @ Paper Riot
Same here. I have no problem with books that revisit familiar ground (I think it's pretty unavoidable) so long as there's something novel about the journey.
DeleteThanks for stopping by!
I definitely agree with the fresh twist in the concept! :)
ReplyDeleteBtW thanks for Following & Commenting on my site, just followed you :)
Marissa @ http://www.fortheloveoffilmandnovels.com/
The more unique a take is on a familiar idea, the more likely I am to like a book.
DeleteThanks for stopping by and following!
I completely agree :)
ReplyDeleteNew follower via GFC
Thanks for checking out My FF and following :)
Samantha @ the secret life of a bookworm
Thanks for dropping by and following!
DeleteI agree 100%!
ReplyDeleteNew follower! :)
Thanks for stopping by and following!
DeleteI like your answer. I especially like a unique retelling.
ReplyDeletenew follower
Thanks for stopping by Book Sojourner!
The more unique, the better! Thanks for dropping by and following!
DeleteGood answer! :) As long as there's something new about the book, I can enjoy it.
ReplyDeleteThanks for stopping by my blog! I'm an old GFC follower.
Me too. Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteThanks for stopping by my feature! Old follower!
ReplyDelete-Amanda P
Where the Night Kind Roam (Formally Paranormal ROmance)
Thanks for dropping by!
DeleteThanks for checking out my blog! I'm following you back now :)
ReplyDelete-Kate the Book Buff